This was the question that occurred to me after listening to Bill Keller, Executive Editor of the New York Times, and Alan Rusbridger, editor of The Guardian, last night at a discussion at Columbia University (well reported by Micah Sifry here).
There were several striking revelations from the discussion, though I am not sure that they were those intended by Rusbridger and Keller.
Rusbridger said that the Guardian had now completed its reporting of the cables, but it was clear from what...
Published by HuffPo today:
Amid the sound and fury of the reaction to WikiLeaks, something is missing. Whether hostile or supportive, politicians and commentators on all sides have managed to miss the real point. The contents of the leaked cables should demand a deep reflection on our foreign policy. That this has not happened tells a sorry story about our very democracy.
On the right, and indeed center, the reaction has been hysteria. Politicians have lined up to decry the threat...
As the airwaves and Internet fill with loud voices proclaiming certain truths, it’s worth taking a quiet moment to remember two men who proved, mathematically, that there was no such thing as absolute and complete truth. Kurt Gödel (pictured) and Ludwig Wittgenstein are rightly renowned in the esoteric worlds of logic and philosophy. But although their intent was never overtly political, their work has a deep political significance. In a way, these two logicians proved the...
The following appeared in the Financial Times, which I have long treasured as the most truly subversive of newspapers. This short article provides a rare pleasure - a profound, concise and it appears wholly unintended yet devastating insight into the true nature of the current economic and cultural system (a similar insight is to be found in the revelation that a toothbrush I recently bought came with a CD-rom with which to programme the device). Such signs are perhaps faint signals...
I have been pondering the news that George Clooney and the Enough Project are deploying a surveillance satellite in an attempt to deter genocide in Sudan. The satellite, whose capability has been rented at considerable cost, will apparently be deployed above "trouble spots" on the border dividing North and South Sudan, looking out for troop movements and other indicators of imminent mass killing. The data will be interpreted at Harvard University and will also be available online....
Micah Sifry, one of the two political-tech gurus behind the Personal Democracy Forum (PDF) (the other is Andrew Rasiej), has kindly posted my remarks to the #PDFLeaks "flash" conference last Saturday in New York City. It was a great discussion, with a lot of smart people, including Arianna Huffington and Charles Ferguson, trying to grapple with the implications of the Wiki-drama. You can see it all here.
One striking thing about the discussion, and indeed about WikiLeaks, is that it...
Posted in Huffington Post today.
It will take a long time, perhaps many years, for the full impact of the WikiLeaks disclosure of thousands of US diplomatic cables to become known. Make no mistake: this is an event of historic importance -- for all governments, and not only the US.
As politicians of all sides bellow their condemnation of WikiLeaks, governments are with some desperation trying to pretend that it's business as usual. But the truth is that something very dramatic in the...
I did an interview on the BBC yesterday on Wikileaks, along with Bill Keller, the Executive Editor of the venerable New York Times, which has published a few of the leaked diplomatic cables. Keller made a startling admission - the New York Times took all the cables it intended to publish to the US government to get their permission and edits before the Times published. Extraordinary! I replied that one conclusion from Keller's remarkable confession was that one should not turn...
Too much to say about this story right now. I've been tweeting about it all day (@carneross) as I read each telegram on the Wikileaks site. It's like being back at work at the Foreign Office reading the daily folder of telegrams. I miss it! But my initial observations are: 1) this will damage US diplomacy, for sure; 2) it will damage several governments mentioned in the cables, especially Yemen (see this devastating telegram); 3) it will take a while and a lot of...
A week ago, it appears that Moroccan forces violently shut down the protest camps of unarmed Sahrawis outside the occupied territory's capital, Laayoune. The Sahrawis, who numbered approximately 20,000, were unarmed and protesting peacefully. This incident highlights the reality of occupation for Sahrawis in the territory and puts paid to the claims of Morocco's propagandists that all is well under Moroccan rule. One such wrote an article in Foreign Policy magazine, repeating...