A simple guide to Palestine's application for membership of the United Nations

There's a lot of confusion about the PLO's likely attempt this week to gain full membership of the UN.  In particular, many commentators (and the PLO itself) often refer to the initiative as an attempt to gain "recognition" by the UN, which it is not.  The UN does not recognise states; only other states can recognise states (however, UN membership would undoubtedly boost Palestine's claim to be a state).

 

As a British diplomat at the UN, I helped negotiate Palestine's last "upgrade" in its status in 1998, when the UK was the Presidency of the EU.  The main negotiation for that General Assembly resolution was between the EU, which controls a large number of votes at the GA, and the Arab Group, which supported the PLO's initiative.

 

Here are some of the key issues:

 

The Process

To become a member of the United Nations, a state has to apply to the UN Secretariat which then will refer the application to the UN Security Council.  The UNSC then has to decide whether to recommend the application to the General Assembly, which then has to vote by a 2/3rds majority to accept the country as a member.  This most recently happened in July when South Sudan became the 193rd member of the UN (a process shepherded by Independent Diplomat, as the Republic of South Sudan is one of our clients).

 

What is likely to happen

 

First, the UNSC...

At this point, the PLO has yet to present an actual draft of any resolution to go before the UNSC, so we still don't know exactly what it will consist of.  It may be a simple application for membership, or it may be (as I would have recommended) a fuller description of the necessary outlines of an equitable, just and lawful solution to the Israel/Palestine dispute (and thus harder for the US, which claims to support such an outcome, to oppose).

The US has said that it will veto any application for full membership by Palestine.  We can therefore expect that the resolution will not pass (it will be interesting also to see who else votes against or abstains: I suspect very few, as most will prefer to hide behind a US veto, playing to the Arab gallery).  In this case, it is likely that the PLO will then offer a different resolution to the General Assembly for Palestine to become a state observer.

 

Then, the General Assembly...

 

Since any application for membership has to be approved by the Security Council, the General Assembly cannot itself make Palestine a member (there is a small chance that the PLO may try to use the "Uniting for Peace" procedure to circumvent the UNSC blockage and have the GA take up the membership issue, but I think this unlikely to succeed: I will explain why below).

 

Instead, the Palestinians are likely to present a resolution to make Palestine an observer state at the UN.  At the moment, the PLO is allowed various rights at the GA, including a seat and the right to propose agenda items.  But it is not acknowledged as a state by the GA.  The likely resolution that the PLO might present would change this.  But again, we have yet to see precisely what such a resolution would consist of (the PLO has not circulated any draft text of a resolution).  And any such resolution would likely be subjected to heavy textual negotiation before a vote, if the Palestinians want to maximise the number of votes in support (alternatively, they may rush a vote to make a political point, assessing that they have sufficient support).  Any textual negotiation would be complicated (the GA has 193 members, organized into different regional groups, many of whom would have views on the resolution) and would therefore take time.

 

However, we can expect that such a resolution would easily pass the simple majority required (unlike full membership, only a simple majority of the GA would be required in this instance).  This would therefore result in Palestine being given enhanced status at the GA, roughly equivalent to that of the Vatican or Switzerland before it became a full member of the UN (but, again, all depends on what is actually in the resolution).

 

The consequences...

For Palestine:

Are many.  In particular, the PLO believe that such a GA resolution would significantly enhance Palestine's claim to be a state.  This would, they believe, bring them important international benefits, including the right to join various international bodies, including in particular the International Criminal Court (the ICC).  They are probably right in this, but each international body, including the ICC, has different rules and procedures of membership and none are to be taken for granted and rendered irrelevant by any decision of the GA. 

 

However, on the ICC, where the Palestinians have already sought its jurisdiction over the Occupied Territories under article 12(3) of the Rome statute, it is likely that the GA decision will enhance Palestine's argument that it is in fact a state.  This makes it more likely that the ICC will decide to exercise its jurisdiction over the Occupied Territories.  The PLO believes that this will act as a deterrrent against Israel's military actions in the West Bank and Gaza (a debatable point of course, since Israel emphatically rejects the ICC's right to exercise such jurisdiction).  Less mentioned is that ICC jurisdiction also has the potential to bring Hamas, which is like Israel alleged to have committed various awar crimes, under the ICC's scrutiny.  The ever-excellent Colum Lynch has a good article at his Turtle Bay blog on this issue.

 

Politically, the PLO believe that the resolution will give Palestine a kind of legal and political "parity" with Israel, as well as increase the pressure for Israel to return to the table to negotiate a lasting deal, based on the 2-state solution with the '67 borders etc etc..  The more extravagant claims of some Palestinian leaders however that such a decision will automatically mean that any future UN decisions, for instance at the Security Council, will be under Chapter VII of the UN charter, and thus obligatory for Israel to implement, are not justified.  The UN Security Council makes its own mind up on such matters, and as long as the US remains a permanent member, we can expect that the Council will be prevented from taking such forceful action (assuming that other members would agree in the first place, which many would not).  This assessment reinforces an overall feeling I have that the legal and political consequences of this initiative are in general being overstated.  Susan Rice has a point when saying that the consequences of the initiative on the ground are nil (though, in my view, that does not mean that the initiative is not worthwhile).  That said, already and at a minimum, the PLO has succeeded in putting the issue of Palestine at the top of the international agenda for UNGA Ministerial week.  This is no small achievement in a year of such extraordinary events.

 

For Israel:

Less good.  The likely thumping majority at the GA for enhanced status for Palestine will underline Israel's international isolation.  However, Israel is entirely used to such isolation at the UN, where every year a raft of resolutions are passed that are critical of Israel.  The Israelis claim with some justification that they are singled out at the UN, where many repressive and unpleasant regimes are ignored.  It is debatable whether this episode will significantly add to the already considerable pressure on Israel to return to the negotiating table.  Israel is correctly more concerned about the significant cooling of its relationships with Egypt and Turkey, in its region.  The UN initiative may have the opposite effect to that intended, not least by making the current Israeli government yet more resistant to pressure to re-engage.  But more qualified observers in and of Israel are better judges than me.

 

For the US:

 

All bad.  Despite the President's undertakings last year in his GA speech to support a 2-state solution based on exactly the parameters that everyone else agrees (with the exception of Israel), the US will be isolated at the UN in blocking the Palestinian initiative.  This will undoubtedly damage the US image in the Middle East in particular.  The desperate efforts by the US to stave off this diplomatic mess by getting Israel and the PLO to agree to talk again look unlikely to succeed in time.  If they do succeed, the initiative may, in a sense, have helped US efforts by forcing the issue to a head, and pressurizing Israel to the table (though the US would be loth to admit it).  But if they fail, as they appear likely to do, the fundamental weakness, if not to say bankruptcy, of US mediation efforts will be exposed in a very embarrassing fashion.  US arguments that the Palestinian initiative will damage the peace process are now treated with considerable and justifiable scepticism, as there is no substantive peace process to speak of, just lots of people (Quartet, Tony Blair etc) talking about a peace process.

 

I will add to this blog later, with commentary on the role of the EU and the PLO in particular, whose motives in this have yet to be fully analysed (you will note that it is the PLO that is leading this initiative, reflecting their traditional role as the international representative of the Palestinian people).  I will also add a note on the "Uniting for Peace" procedure and further updates as the week plays out (there is a technical description of the origins of UFP here).

Comments

One of the most time

One of the most time consuming, and therefore prohibitive, aspects of starting up a project like a home garden is the driving around to a million stores, and having to come home between each one to unload. home inspector

The first time I was

The first time I was introduced to a Zebra was by my artisan uncle. He showed me a wooden sculpture of a Zebra, beautifully painted with black and white stripes. http://www.zebrastripecontrasters.net

Any criminal security

Any criminal security attorney is in charge of defending traders who are charged together with crimes and also felonies. They symbolize their clients inside the court regarding law and also speak for the kids. They can easily either become directly approached by way of a client or perhaps designated from the court regarding law to take action. criminallawattorney.org

Common fashion atlanta

Common fashion atlanta divorce attorneys season is obviously dazzling. Only the particular classic types which advocate the essential principle really can hold peoples' hearts. There are usually several vintage styles under and they all are both vintage and trend. classicfashion.org

I will keep visiting this

I will keep visiting this blog very often. It is good to see you verbalize from the heart and your clarity on this important subject on trees can be easily observed. nourbesephotographym

That is definitely an easy

That is definitely an easy application. Personal Training Singapore

For vehicle owners, The

For vehicle owners, The Hillford Condo takes less than 15 minutes to drive to the business hub and vibrant Orchard Road shopping district, via Bukit Timah Expressway (BKE) and Ayer Rajah Expressway (AYE). A wonderful and unique lifestyle awaits you. Please see The Hillford Condo project details and units available for more information. condo near beauty world mrt

I certainly believe that

I certainly believe that Palestine should be a recognised state, but that's about as far as my concern for this issue goes. - Movie Rob

Future residents are within

Future residents are within walking distance to Bishan Junction 8 and a short drive to Ang Mo Kio Hub from Sky Vue Condo. With such a short drive to the city area as well as the orchard and bugis area, entertainment for your love ones and family will come at a stone’s throw away from Sky Vue Condo Sky Vue contact us

Will definitely keep this in

Will definitely keep this in mind. This is one good post. Explore more about counselors in baton rouge.

Cool page you got here! Click

Cool page you got here! Click here: win a car uk

good work you are doing nice.

good work you are doing nice.

The condo’s facilities

The condo’s facilities provide full family entertainment needs for your family and loved ones. Indulge in a serene and tranquil lifestyle right in the heart of Bartley.
Kensington Square Project Details

Id certainly will talk about

Id certainly will talk about this blog with my group. I would mention that most of us visitors are really endowed to exist here while Many individuals will feel very much helped
1600 microsoft points free

I think they should better

I think they should better end the war. It's really annoying the citizen to doing their activities in that situation.
settlement quote

With the right guide, I think

With the right guide, I think the Palestinians could join UN smoothly. It is quite important to be done by the Palestinians, given the many problems and wars that occur in this country. dentist houston

The person who made ​​it must

The person who made ​​it must be sure that there will be many people from many countries understand this. This is one thing that many countries are still questioned by the laity. house md online free

Situated at a strategic

Situated at a strategic location between Egypt, Syria and Arabia, and the birthplace of Judaism and Christianity, the region has a long and tumultuous history as a crossroads for religion, culture, commerce, and politics. Thanks.
Regards,
Creative Bioscience

Things are very open and

Things are very open and intensely clear explanation of issues. was truly information. Your website is very beneficial. Appreciate your sharing.
cheap dedicated server

Things are very open and

Things are very open and intensely clear explanation of issues. was truly information. Your website is very beneficial. Appreciate your sharing.
funeral plans

I’m glad Yahoo pointed me to

I’m glad Yahoo pointed me to it. I was able to get the know-how I was searching so badly for days now.Thank You very much for your really good web page. Have a good day.It's very useful for everyone for sure.
get fast loans

I would like to appreciate

I would like to appreciate your hard work you did write this post, Thanks for sharing this valuable post.
excess omega 3 side effects

pour tondeuse a gazon

OASIS is a massive virtual

OASIS is a massive virtual galaxy where your avatar can be anything you want it to be, it's a place where you can live, play, quest on any of the thousands of planets.
buy likes on instagram

Things are very open and

Things are very open and intensely clear explanation of issues. was truly information. Your website is very beneficial. Appreciate your sharing
purchase instagram likes

Things are very open and

Things are very open and intensely clear explanation of issues. was truly information. Your website is very beneficial. Appreciate your sharing.
Catering w Warszawie

i like to see it lap the

i like to see it lap the miles
FIND-WEDDING
WEDDING-PLANNINGGUIDE
PLANTHEWEDDINGS

The UN Security Council makes

The UN Security Council makes its own mind up on such matters, and as long as the US remains a permanent member, we can expect that the Council will be prevented from taking such forceful action (assuming that other http://www.pass4suretests.com/test/350-018.html members would agree in the first place, which many would not). This assessment reinforces an overall feeling I have that the legal and political consequences of this initiative are in general being overstated. Susan Rice has a point when saying that the consequences of the initiative on the ground are nil (though, in my view, that does not mean that the initiative is not worthwhile). pass4sure 350-018 tests That said, already and at a minimum, the PLO has succeeded in putting the issue of Palestine at the top of the international agenda for UNGA Ministerial week. This is no small achievement in a year of such extraordinary events.

Citizens of Plestines knows

Citizens of Plestines knows the best what is right for them.
Southlake Texas Real Estate

This will be cool go for it I

This will be cool go for it I will use it. Thank You wedding concepts

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.