Are the #cablegate cables too important to be left to WikiLeaks, New York Times, Guardian etc?

This was the question that occurred to me after listening to Bill Keller, Executive Editor of the New York Times, and Alan Rusbridger, editor of The Guardian, last night at a discussion at Columbia University (well reported by Micah Sifry here).

There were several striking revelations from the discussion, though I am not sure that they were those intended by Rusbridger and Keller.

 

Rusbridger said that the Guardian had now completed its reporting of the cables, but it was clear from what he said that the Guardian had not read all the cables.  Instead they had run word searches on the database.  Keller said the same.  Both implied that WikiLeaks itself had used the same technique.  In other words, one can infer, no one has read all the cables.

 

This is understandable given the huge volume of cables.  But the description given by Rusbridger of the method the Guardian had used to search the database did not inspire confidence.  He said more or less: "we ran all the word searches we could think of and looked at what came up".  He added that after this process, the Guardian had invited readers to suggest what searches they wanted run on the data, and this had thrown up about two thousand suggestions, some of which Rusbridger described as the usual conspiracy theories.

 

Secondly, Keller's answer to a question from me provoked similar doubts about the New York Times's understanding of the data.  I had asked why the Times had not reported the extraordinary cable revealing that the US was conducting secret aerial surveillance of Lebanon (presumably of Hizbollah positions) at the request of the Lebanese government, data that is presumably then shared with Israel: a rather toxic revelation for the Lebanese, to put it mildly.  Keller claimed to know nothing of the cable, and suggested that this was why the Times had not reported it.  Either he is being economical with the truth, and the Times had succumbed to US pressure not to publish this potentially destabilizing revelation (he had earlier confirmed again that the Times showed every cable it intended to report to the State Dept beforehand), or he really did not know about it.  Neither inference is very encouraging.

 

Again, we were treated to the rather smug presumption from both editors that since no harm had been proven from the leaked cables, no harm had been done.  The moderator did not press them on the several cases of cables whose release is potentially harmful, and where there appears little public interest in their publication (I have discussed some of these cables in this article).  Another panellist, Jack Goldsmith, a former US Assistant Attorney General, repeated the very mistaken suggestion that there was little truly revelatory in the cables, a claim frankly that can only be made by someone who has not read them.

 

Despite these evident weaknesses in the Guardian's and Times' comprehension of the data, both Rusbridger and Keller repeated that they would not countenance releasing the whole stock of cables.  Rusbridger claimed that the public would not understand them and that there would therefore be little news in them (perhaps he was jet-lagged but I really did not understand his point).  Keller contradicted him and said that he thought that lots of people would rummage around in the data, including experts, causing a "cacophony" (heaven forbid!).  But he suggested, as he has before, that the public cannot be trusted with the data (but of course, he did not need to add, the New York Times can be).

 

All in all, Keller and Rusbridger gave a rather unimpressive exposition of these papers' handling of the most important release of diplomatic and political data in recent times.  I should add that both were notably dismissive and critical of Assange.   Keller in particular went out of his way to make some silly and sneering remarks about Assange, which reflected rather worse on Keller than they did on Assange himself. Keller described Assange as a mere "source" and one got the impression that Keller was distinctly unhappy with WikiLeaks' assault on the authority of newspapers to disseminate only what they see fit as news.

 

I will leave to others to comment on what seems to me, as it did to others, a turning point in the culture of journalism.  Jack Goldsmith in particular made some very cogent points on this score, pointing out that a fundamental shift was underway towards more open data, posing a great challenge to government but also, he did not need to add, to the established citadels of conventional journalism, like the Times and the Guardian. 

 

On the part that interests me, namely the political content of the cables, I was left with the following conclusions:

 

Neither the newspapers nor WikiLeaks have the capacity fully to analyse the full stock of leaked cables, thanks to the sheer volume of cables but also their extremely broad and manifold political significance. Nonetheless, the newspapers have decided to stop reporting the cables, and believe that they have no duty to release further cables to the public.

 

Secondly, neither newspaper necessarily has the capacity to understand the potential impact of the cables.  This is because the data is simply too complicated and voluminous for any one authority to claim to understand in full.  Rusbridger at one point commented that an Indian journalist told him that the cables from New Delhi alone would produce thirty front page headlines in India.

 

I don't particularly blame these newspapers for not being able to command this vast stock of material, but I do think they are being rather arrogant in assuming that they can.  What should be done?

 

I too am hesitant to suggest that all the data be released in full, for the usual reasons.  But I do think that a more comprehensive method needs to be established to handle releases, archive and file the data, and to analyse it properly and fully.  Some kind of body needs to be established, not government obviously, comprising a network of regional political experts, but also with a transparent and credible method to assess the potential danger of releasing certain cables.  Perhaps the Guardian and the Times could set up such a body, rather than handling this material through their existing news teams.  Perhaps some brave foundation could fund it.  It would be a very necessary service.  For it was clear to me last night, that for all the contribution they have made in bringing this remarkable material to public sight, neither the Times, nor the Guardian, nor WikiLeaks itself is fully capable of handling, analysing and editing this data in the manner which it deserves.

Comments

Several buses are available

Several buses are available near Sengkang West Way Condo along with shopping centers and restaurants. Sengkang West Way Condo is also near Waterway Point, the shopping, dining and entertainment hub which is scheduled to open in 2 years time. Also, it is right beside Punggol Waterfront. Entertainment for your loved ones and friends are therefore at your fingertips with the full condo facilities as well as the amenities near Sengkang West Way Condo. Sengkang West Way Condo

For vehicle owners, Sky Vue

For vehicle owners, Sky Vue Condo takes less than 15 minutes to drive to the business hub and vibrant Orchard Road shopping district, via Central Expressway (CTE). Skyvue

For vehicle owners, The

For vehicle owners, The Inflora Condo takes less than 25 minutes to drive to the business hub and vibrant Orchard Road shopping district, via Pan-Island Expressway (PIE) and East Coast Expressway(ECP). The Inflora Project Details

The Panorama is also near to

The Panorama is also near to Nex Shopping Centre as well as the buzzling Toa Payoh area. Entertainment for your loved ones and friends is therefore at your fingertips with the full condo facilities as well as the amenities around Ang Mo Kio. The Panorama Location

I just found this blog and

I just found this blog and have high hopes for it to continue. Keep up the great work, its hard to find good ones. I have added to my favorites. And the concept of Thank You.click here

The geography and climate in

The geography and climate in the Caribbean region varies: Some islands in the region have relatively flat terrain of non-volcanic origin.

To say that you should have

To say that you should have let the south go its own way and not engaged in the human tragedy.

Your point on the civil war

Your point on the civil war is completely wrong.
192.168.1.1
192.168.0.1
192.168.2.1

Are you tired of finding a

Are you tired of finding a date online? Everyone's doing it these days, but like any endeavor you shouldn't put all your eggs in one basket.

If you want to impress

If you want to impress someone be prepared! Before the date do something that relaxes you, exercise, reading, yoga, singing your favorite song, whatever puts you in an easy going, happy mood. Wash yourself, put on antiperspirant/deodorant, brush your teeth, brush your hair, and don't forget to wear clean clothes!

After reading your post, I

After reading your post, I have learned that both Rusbridger and Keller repeated that they would not countenance releasing the whole stock of cables.
http://guocolandtp180.org
watch tp180

You can't just ask customers

You can't just ask customers what they want and then try to give that to them. By the time you get it built, they'll want something new.
customized essay

But innovation comes from

But innovation comes from people meeting up in the hallways or calling each other at 10:30 at night with a new idea, or because they realized something that shoots holes in how we've been thinking about a problem.
hate writing papers

Hi, interesting post. I have

Hi, interesting post. I have been wondering about this topic, so thanks for posting. I'll definitely be subscribing to your site. Keep up the good work.
Singapore Condo
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ht0qPpyfGX8

Former Tai Keng Court has

Former Tai Keng Court has full and unique facilities, which includes a guard house, clubhouse, children's playground, swimming pool, piano room, pool room, indoor gym, hydrotherapy beds, hydrotherapy baths, reading room, function room, onsen, jacuzzi.
Tai Keng Court

I heard rumors that Wikileaks

I heard rumors that Wikileaks would have the main office located in Chinatown? Could it be fleeting or just rumors?

The condo’s facilities

The condo’s facilities provide full family entertainment needs for your family and loved ones. Indulge in a serene and tranquil lifestyle right in the heart of Bugis.
Several buses are available near Rocher Road and Beach Road along with shopping centers and restaurants.
DUO Residences Project Details

Lush Acres EC has full and

Lush Acres EC has full and unique facilities, which includes a guard house, clubhouse, Function Room & Indoor Gym Tennis Court, 50m Freeform Pool Pool Deck, Wading Pool, Splash Pool & Family Pool Jacuzzi & Hydro Spa, BBQ Area Dining and Play Fountain, Fitness Alcove & Children’s Playground and Garden Trail.
Sengkang EC

In October 2010, Assange told

In October 2010, Assange told a major Moscow newspaper that "The Kremlin had better brace itself for a coming wave of WikiLeaks disclosures about Russia". Interesting business?

In July of 2007, WikiLeaks

In July of 2007, WikiLeaks released Afghan War Diary and seascapes, a compilation of more than 76,900 documents about the War in Afghanistan not previously available to the public.

I'm really crazy about this

I'm really crazy about this post. It's truly amazing. I highly appreciate the ability to enjoy such a nice piece of art as this post.
personal memoir

If I want to Spend Less on

If I want to Spend Less on Postage, what should I do? The paper's print version remains the largest local metropolitan newspaper in the United States and third-largest newspaper overall, behind The Wall Street Journal and USA Today.

J Gateway is a new and

J Gateway is a new and upcoming condominium located in Boon Lay Way, Jurong East area. It is located right beside JCube, and the upcoming Westgate and Jem. With expected completion in mid 2016, it comprises of 4 towers with 783 units and stands 38 storeys tall.
J Gateway

Louis Vuitton Bags have been

Louis Vuitton Bags have been ever popular since they entered the fashion scene. Buy handbags and accessories for women from http://pinterest.com/lvlouisvuitton/.

The thrust of the resolution

The thrust of the resolution is to demand a ceasefire and to impose various military.192.168.1.1

Cablegate cables useful

Cablegate cables useful espeically when we are talking about WikiLeaks. This stuff is useul for matlab model analysis too.

Belgravia Villas has full and

Belgravia Villas has full and unique facilities, which includes a guard house, clubhouse, children's playground, swimming pool, piano room, pool room, indoor gym, hydrotherapy beds, hydrotherapy baths, reading room, function room, onsen, jacuzzi.
The condo’s facilities provide full family entertainment needs for your family and loved ones. Indulge in a serene and tranquil lifestyle right in the heart of Ang Mo Kio.
Belgravia Villas Project Details

Our subconscious minds have

Our subconscious minds have no sense of humor, play no jokes and cannot tell the difference between reality and an imagined thought or image. What we continually think about eventually will manifest in our lives. smallworkloans.com

I'm curious to find out what

I'm curious to find out what happened with Assange lately. It was a trial and there were some nasty accusations. I want to know what is the sequel of this.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.